Can Güney Aksakalli

Can Güney Aksakalli

Notes from my journey


Quicksort, Insertion Sort and Radix Sort Comparison

Complexity of an algorithm is determined as consumed resources like time and space. It depends not only on the number of input elements but also on their order. In this work, I tried to demonstrate how order of inputs affects the time complexity for different sorting algorithms. In particular, I experimented with quicksort, insertion sort and radix sort. Here are Big-O time complexities of these sorting algorithms:

Algorithm Worst case Best case Average case
Quicksort
Insertion sort
Radix sort

In this experiment, the input is a pair of number and word. First, the file will be read and then numbers will be sorted in descending order with each sorting algorithm. Here is how the input looks like:

1000	to
999	dedicated
998	here
997	be
996	to
995	us
994	for
993	rather
...

In order to test boundary cases for different input orders, three different input versions are used:

  • data1.txt: already sorted in ascending order
  • data2.txt: random order (sorted by word)
  • data3.txt: already sorted in descending order

Here are average runtime for each file and algorithm:

Quicksort, Insertion Sort and Radix Sort runtime chart

Algorithm data1.txt data2.txt data3.txt
Quicksort 1980 ms 680 ms 1840 ms
Insertion Sort 11270 ms 5890 ms 400 ms
Radix Sort 680 ms 690 ms 690 ms

Based on the result:

  • Quicksort: Already sorted and reverse sorted inputs are the worst cases. data2.txt has the best run-time for three inputs because it is random.
  • Insertion Sort: The best case is the already sorted input and the worst case is the already reverse sorted input. In this experiment, the task is to sort the numbers in descending so data3.txt is the best case and data1.txt is the worst case.
  • Radix Sort:: The run-times are almost the same for all inputs because radix sort’s performance is independent from input order. Thus, linearly sorted inputs are not worst or best case for insertion sort.

This experiment shows that, order of the input is important as input size. Although size of inputs are the same, the order changes the runtime dramatically.

Here is the code in C++:

References

  • Cormen, Thomas H. Introduction to algorithms. MIT press, 2009.